As Major League Baseball (MLB) continues to innovate and modernize the game, the Cincinnati Reds are taking a cautious approach to the new Automated Ball-Strike System (ABS) being piloted this spring.
With the Cactus League season kicking off in Goodyear, Arizona, the Reds’ manager Terry Francona has instructed his major league players to avoid using the experimental ABS challenge system, reserving its use for the minor leaguers.
This decision underscores the ongoing debate about the future of umpiring and technology in baseball.
MLB’s Automated Ball-Strike System: A New Era in Umpiring
The ABS challenge system represents a significant shift in how balls and strikes are called in baseball.
The system allows hitters, pitchers, and catchers to challenge an umpire’s call on a ball or strike. Each team is given two challenges per game, and if a challenge is successful, the team retains it.
This system is being tested in five parks in Arizona and eight in Florida during spring training, with plans to implement it in all Triple-A parks this season.
The Reds’ Approach: Focus on Traditional Strategies
While the ABS system is generating buzz, Terry Francona has made it clear that his major league players will not be using it during spring training.
Francona believes that since the system will not be used in the regular season, practicing with it now would only create confusion. He stated, *We’re not using it in the regular season, so why work on a strategy we’re not going to use? It just muddies the waters.*
Find the best accommodations
Check availability at 5* hotels, guest houses and apartments rated "superb" or "exceptional" by visitors just like you.
NO RESERVATION FEES
CHECK AVAILABILITY FOR YOUR DATES HERE
However, Francona is open to his minor leaguers using the ABS system. He noted that these younger players have experience with the technology and can benefit from the practice.
This cautious yet open-minded approach reflects Francona’s desire to prepare his team effectively for the upcoming season without unnecessary distractions.
The Implementation and Reception of ABS
MLB first tested a full ABS system in the independent Atlantic League in 2019. Since then, the system has been refined and introduced in various minor leagues.
In 2022, the ABS challenge system was used in the Low-Class A Florida State League, and by 2024, it was being used exclusively in Triple-A, replacing the full ABS system.
Positive Feedback and Future Prospects
According to MLB executive vice president of baseball operations Morgan Sword, the ABS challenge system has received favorable feedback from players, minor-league managers, coaches, and fans.
Sword emphasized the importance of gathering both quantitative and qualitative data this spring to evaluate the system’s effectiveness. He stated, *We’re going to be looking at a mix of quantitative and qualitative factors. I think one of the biggest ones is just what players and coaches think about it, their experience with the system.*
The earliest the ABS challenge system could be implemented in regular-season play is 2026. Until then, MLB is encouraging teams to experiment with the system during spring training to gain familiarity and provide feedback.
How the ABS Challenge System Works
The ABS challenge system utilizes the Hawk-Eye technology, which provides a computer image of the call.
The strike zone is determined by the width of home plate and a percentage of each player’s height, measured by MLB.
When a challenge is made, the umpire calls time, and the computer’s decision is displayed on the scoreboard. The entire process averages 17 seconds.
Strategic Use of Challenges
In the minor leagues, challenges are most commonly used in later innings and in critical counts with either two strikes or three balls.
However, Francona expressed concerns about players learning the optimal times to use challenges, which could complicate their preparation for the season. He mentioned, *If you leave it open to only use it if it’s important — I’m using it in my first at-bat. It’s important to me. I need a hit. We’re going to stay away from that.*
The Future of Umpiring in Baseball
The introduction of the ABS challenge system is part of MLB’s broader efforts to modernize the game and improve accuracy in umpiring.
While traditionalists may be wary of such changes, the positive feedback and successful trials in the minor leagues suggest that technology could play a significant role in the future of baseball.
Balancing Tradition and Innovation
As MLB navigates the balance between tradition and innovation, the cautious approach taken by teams like the Cincinnati Reds highlights the complexities involved.
While the ABS challenge system offers potential benefits, its implementation at the major league level will require careful consideration and widespread acceptance from players, coaches, and fans.
For more information on the ABS challenge system and the Cincinnati Reds’ approach to spring training, you can read the full article on The Athletic here.
Get the latest sent right to your inbox
- Schools Covered
- College Football Articles
- Men's College Basketball Articles
- Men's College Soccer Articles
- Women's College Basketball Articles
- Olympic Athlete Articles
- Men's College Baseball Articles
- College Sports Media Professionals Articles
- Hall of Fame Member Articles
- Former College Player Articles
- Game Previews